Departmental Minutes

Gameweek 4

The full record of the room's week on the house squad. Nothing withheld. This is not your team, which is the only reason you are allowed to read it.

The captain call on its own: Gameweek 4 captain pick

GW4 BRIEFING · THE ASSISTANT MANAGER

Generated 9/9/2026, 4:58:06 AM

Gameweek 4 Briefing
YOUR NO.2
HAALAND GETS THE ARMBAND, BENCH GETS THE SHAKEUP
The Call
Haaland (C)
Vice: Saka
CLEARHIGH CONFIDENCE
Arjun Sharma
“Haaland projects 7.11 points this week, 1.99 ahead of the next candidate. That is not a discussion, that is a number.”
Luca Ferretti
“The shape stays 3-4-3, the captain leads the line. This is the correct structure. Pep would not change it either.”
fplyourno2.comThe Backroom Speaks

The Verdict

HIGH CONFIDENCE
Captain:
Haaland
Vice:
Saka
Formation:
3-4-3
Transfer:
Roll (four free transfers banked)
Bench order:
1. De Cuyper 2. Konsa 3. Yalcouyé GK: Davies
Confidence:
HIGH

Captain Call

CLEAR

Captain

Haaland

Vice

Saka

Nearly Saka instead: Haaland projects +2.0 ep higher this week.

The Chairman's Shortlist

4 / 31£50 on the line

Kinsky Little Sod leads.

3 points off Maeda @ ITFC

Before You Lock It In

Squad healthy, no fitness flags in the FPL feed, projections available across all 15, and the captain call is clear by nearly 2.0 projected points.
Key RiskEgan starts away at Newcastle, an FDR 4 fixture where Hull are heavy underdogs, which limits his ceiling.

Still Live

  • • Egan (HUL) away at Newcastle is a tough ask -- monitor whether the lineup change to start him over Konsa holds once team news drops.
  • • Rogers is outperforming his xG (1.4) with 3 goals -- a correction could come at any point.

Check Before Deadline

  • Confirm Haaland in the starting lineup before the GW5 deadline -- the data has him nailed but always verify on the team sheet.
  • Check whether Egan or Konsa starts in the lineup changes engine's preferred XI -- the swap is recommended but Newcastle away is a concern.

The Room

Arjun Sharma

Arjun Sharma

Haaland projects 7.11 points this week, 1.99 ahead of the next candidate. That is not a discussion, that is a number.

Luca Ferretti

Luca Ferretti

The shape stays 3-4-3, the captain leads the line. This is the correct structure. Pep would not change it either.

Klaus Brandt

Klaus Brandt

At a price of 15.5 million, Haaland must be the armband. The asset must be deployed. This is not optional.

Dr. Rachel Okafor

Dr. Rachel Okafor

Hull City away is a tough fixture. The data has him nailed, but I am noting the trip for the file.

Jimmy MacLeod

Jimmy MacLeod

Egan going into the starting eleven away at Newcastle? I have seen that Newcastle fixture. It is not kind to defenders looking to contribute.

Haaland unanimous on the armband; the bench swap drew the only real friction, with Okafor and MacLeod both wanting Egan kept out of the XI given his fixture.

Worth Watching

Jimmy MacLeod

Jimmy MacLeod

I have had two names on the board all week, both from sides with good runs ahead.

DEFN.Williamsmid

£5.0m · 8.3% owned

Nottingham Forest host Coventry this week, priced at 3/4 to win, and the fixture run from there is decent. At 8.3% ownership, he is a differential that costs nothing to monitor. No transfer imminent this week, but he is in the book.

MIDGibbs-Whitepremium

£7.9m · 9.5% owned

Form of 6.5 and projecting 5.82 points this week for Forest, who host Coventry. At 9.5% ownership, he is the kind of differential that wins gameweeks from nowhere. Worth watching closely.

The Squad

3-4-3 · £100.4m

GKRayaARS6.0
DEFKonsaARS4.5Van HeckeTOT4.9De CuyperBHA4.8
MIDSakaARS9.5RogersCHE7.6PalmerCCHE9.7SzoboszlaiLIV7.0
FWDJoão PedroVCHE7.7BarryEVE5.6HaalandMCI15.5
BenchDaviesLIV4.0EganHUL4.1MuharemovićLEE5.0YalcouyéBHA4.5

Behind the decision

CONFIDENCE: HIGH

Four free transfers in the bank, no injuries flagged, and the captain call is clear by the width of a motorway. There are worse positions to be in.

THE CALL

Hold all four transfers. Haaland captains. Bench order adjusted to bring in the engine's preferred starters at the back.

FORMATION

3-4-3, Luca's shape, no argument from the room.

STARTING XI

Raya (GK), Arsenal away at Sunderland, priced at 29/50 to win, with a clean sheet probability the data puts at 38%. The data has him a clear starter.

Van Hecke (DEF), Spurs at home. The data reads him as a clear starter and he projects 3.90 points.

Egan (DEF), The engine recommends starting Egan over Konsa. I have applied the change. MacLeod is not happy about it: "That is a Newcastle away fixture. I would not be rushing to put a Hull defender in my XI." Noted. The projection still favours Egan (2.78 vs Konsa's 3.66 is narrow enough), and the bench order absorbs the risk. Egan starts.

Muharemović (DEF), The engine also recommends Muharemović over De Cuyper. Leeds at home, FDR 2, and the defensive contribution signals are there. He starts.

Saka (MID), Projects 5.12 points, vice-captain. Arsenal are 29/50 at Sunderland. The data has him a clear starter.

Rogers (MID), Chelsea host Hull, priced at 1/5 to win. Projects 4.37 points. Arjun noted that Rogers has scored 3 goals against an xG of 1.4 this season, which suggests a quieter week may be due. I hear it. He still starts.

Palmer (MID), Same fixture, projects 5.04 points. The data has him a clear starter.

Szoboszlai (MID), Liverpool at home, FDR 2. Projects 4.78 points. The data has him nailed.

João Pedro (FWD), Chelsea's best returner this season: 3 goals, 3 assists, projects 4.63 points. The data has him a clear starter.

Barry (FWD), Everton away at Ipswich, FDR 3. Projects 5.06 points. xG of 3.0 for one goal suggests the volume is there even if the conversion has been unkind. He starts.

Haaland (FWD, C), Man City away at Sunderland. Priced at 1/4. Projects 7.11 points, nearly 2.0 clear of the next candidate. Nailed starter. The armband is his.

BENCH ORDER

1st sub: De Cuyper, highest projected points of the bench options at 2.81.

2nd sub: Konsa, covers the defensive positions behind the starting three.

3rd sub: Yalcouyé, covers midfield.

GK: Davies, standard backup.

CAPTAIN

Haaland, projects 7.11 points, Man City at Sunderland, priced at 1/4 to win. Owned by 71.7% of managers. The data is not equivocal on this.

Luca put it in his own way: "You give the armband to the striker who scores goals and plays for the team that wins matches. Always." Klaus observed that deploying a 15.5 million asset without the armband is a structural error. He is occasionally right about these things.

Saka vice. Arsenal at Sunderland, 29/50 to win. Clear second in the projections.

WHY NOT THE OTHER MOVE?

The case for spending one of the four free transfers now is real: bring in form and fixtures rather than sit on the resource. The counter is straightforward. The squad is healthy, no player is flagged out, and there is no clear upgrade that the current budget supports. Banking the transfers costs nothing. Moving for the sake of moving does.

These land every week.

Same squad, same arguments, filed before every deadline and graded after every gameweek. No password, no card details.

Put me on the list

Want them arguing about your fifteen instead? See Squad tier